Is It Possible to Love Two Men? How do I choose?

Ponder this question for a moment…

Society teaches us that it is wrong to love two men at the same time, or two women for that matter.

At the same time we are taught to love everyone in our family unconditionally.

Is it because that love is not sexual in nature?

Why isn’t is possible, or should I say, why are we taught that it’s wrong to love more than one person romantically and to be sexually attracted to more than one person at the same time?

Think about this while you read this question and our answer…

The Question

I am in love with two men. Both say they love me and eventually want to marry me.

One is my best friend, the person I feel I can talk to about anything, and the person who has always been there for me and who I can communicate with and makes me laugh. However, I am not sexually attracted to him, although I love him and enjoy intimacy other than sexual intimacy. Also in order to have children we will need to have IVF to prevent a genetic disorder, which will mean suffering for me.

The other is not my best friend. We have trouble communicating and he is always running around with his many friends rather than spending quiet time with me at home, although he can be very romantic and loving. However I am incredibly sexually attracted to him and love him, and also I would be able to conceive with him naturally without IVF.

I am confused. I have tried looking inside my heart to determine who I love more…but that doesn’t work as I love them both for different reasons and for different qualities. I have tried writing up a list of things I like and don’t like about both of them but this doesn’t work either. I need to make a decision as I am hurting myself and them. I am scared of making the wrong decision and regretting it later when I realize I chose the wrong person.

My question I suppose is, is it better to marry my best friend even though I don’t desire to have sex with him, as I know that communication will always be easy with him, and will not something that we have to work at. Also I know he will always be there for me, never betray me to his friends, always understand or try to understand my views, and spend more time at home with me instead of constantly going out every night. I suppose my problem here is that sex is an important part of marriage and I am scared I just wont want to do it as often as him as I don’t desire it, which will mean his needs as well as my needs will not be met, and will hurt the relationship.

Or is it better to marry someone who you are incredibly sexually attracted to since sex is a very important aspect of a marriage, and work on the communication, even if it means always having issues that you will have to work hard to resolve because communication between you is something that has never come easily and will require a lot of work because you are each on different wavelengths?

In a way I wish I could put guy #1’s personality in guy #2’s body, then I would have the perfect mate. I just don’t know what to do. I truly love them both, for different reasons. I just don’t know what I should give more importance to in helping me make my decision. I suppose that another resolution would be that since I don’t know who I love more, I would choose that person who loves ME more. In that way I could be more sure about making the right decision. Both have done things to hurt me, and both have done things to show me they love me, albeit in very different ways….so I really don’t know how to get that answer either.

I just want to do the right thing. I have had ample time to think about this and time hasn’t helped, in fact it has gone on too long. Please help me.

Confused Sarah

The answer to Sarah’s question…

Page: 1 2

Dan and Jennifer are the Founders and Senior Editors of AskDanAndJennifer.com, which has been called "the best and most popular Love and Sex advice column on the Internet today". Their videos are some of the most popular videos on YouTube. Don't forget to ask your dating, love, and sex questions in the Ask Dan and Jennifer - Love, & Sex Forums. You should Fan Dan & Jennifer on Facebook and Follow them on Twitter!

Take A Fun Sex Quiz

"Think You Understand Female Orgasms?"

Take The Orgasm Quiz And Find Out The Top 25 Female Orgasm Tips That You Can Use Tonight To Make Her Scream For More.

   

"Think You Know How To Give A Great Blow Job?"

Take The Blow Job Quiz And Find Out The Top 25 Blow Job Tips That You Can Use Tonight To Make Him Scream For More.

   

Check Out These Helpful Resources You May Like...





See More Recommended Resources »

Comment Policy: Keep it positive and on topic. Comments will be promptly deleted if that are 1.) spammy (i.e. keyword like "dating tips" in place of your name, 2.) not related to this article, or 3.) in any way offensive or attacking to anyone. It's OK to disagree but it must be in a respectful and positive manner. Thanks!

  • I'm not sure if you should choose.

    Can you be married to somebody, and then try to bury the other one away from your mind? That's not the right thing to do.
  • Jen
    I am in the same situation as you, Sarah. I have been involved with one man for over 3 years, and now he is ready to get married. I would have never thought twice about marrying him if I hadn't met another man a few months ago. I love both of them for different reasons. Guy #1 sounds a lot like your guy #1. We are very close and can talk about anything. He would rather stay home with me than run around with friends. I am sexually attracted to him but not nearly as much as I am with guy #2. Guy #2 is fun and exciting, but we have a lot of difficulty communicating and at times I can't even think of anything to talk to him about. He still goes out all the time with his friends, and I don't see him settling down anytime soon. Guy #1 sounds like the obvious choice, but I can't seem to forget about guy #2!
  • Sarah
    Hi Jen, its good to hear I am not the only one in this mess! Its a very difficult situation to be in. I think we probably have a few choices:
    1) Choose between the two guys - which may mean that we may regret the decision later on if it doesnt work out or we are not happy with the guy we chose;
    2) Continue dating both guys - which is very stressful for us and would hurt both guys if they found out, and could potentially mean we would lose both guys; or
    3) End it with both guys and look for guy #3 - which means we could potentially risk loosing two great guys and ending up with no one or someone we are not in love with.
    It is very scary and a huge responsibilty to place on ourselves to make this decision which will affect the rest of our lives.
    If only I could help my decision making by knowing who out of the two guys loved ME more. Is there some way of knowing this??
  • kIMBERLY
    Hi Sarah,
    I'm Kimberly and I am in the total same situation also. I have known guy #1 for a year now was his best friend for awhile and we both could not fight our attraction and we ended up together but he could not stop his womanizing ways and cheated on me with my best friend, I dumped him and met guy #2 Who is wonderful too He is sweet and caring and all, but I cannot communicate with him like I can guy #1 He is very intense aand had moments that he snapps on me for no reason other that that he know guy #1 and he knows of my feelings for guy #1. I have told him from the startand i guess i was trying to be honest but then guy#1 started coming around again and trying to see me and i was weak and i would meet him. Now guy #2 got put into jail and is due to come out of ail anyday. My problem is I love guy #1 more ahan guy #2 but i cannot see myself without guy #2 in my life. He is great he helps me with anything i want and treats me really good. He is just not my guy#1 and I wish I could stop loveing guy #1 and spend eternity with guy #2. I knowthat I will have to stop seeing one of them but this is killing me everyday that i spend with indecicision. It is eating me alive knowing I have to let one of these wonderful men go away. What can we do to help us make this decision. My heart cannot take much more I agree with your choices by the way the right answer may well be in letting them both go and meeting guy #3 but how to fill the void of guy #1 and guy #2 because I dont know about you but they are pretty ingrained in my heart and its going to take along time to get over them and i will never forget them. Now that guy #1 wants me to come back I get so happy but then i think about leaving guy #2 I get so sad. Guy #1 says Guy #2 is taunting him by sticking with me even though guy #2 doesnt talk to him.. guy #1 says guy#2 is hanging with me waiting for him to mess up and then he can move in for the kill and take me back away. and he says he learn his lesson he not gonna mess up again. he loves me and he wants me but part of me doubts that. because he has cheated on me before i do have doubts that he can be faithful and i have doubts that i can be now after being with guy #2 .. i am more sexually uninhibited with guy #2 and we have the best sex but i can talk with guy #1 about anything.. help
  • Jen
    Hi again, Sarah. Well, I do know who loves me more. I am certain guy #1 loves me more. We are much closer than guy #2 and me, and have been involved for significantly longer. However, that does not help me make up my mind. I just tell my myself that it is not fair to compare the 2 in that manner because guy #2 has not had as much time to get to know me as guy #1. What if after 3 years with guy #2 he loved me even more than guy #1? There are so many "what ifs" with this whole mess, and I wish there was an easy solution. I agree with your 3 scenarios, though I have no idea which one to go with. If you want to talk further, you can email me at jcs478 at yahoo.com. Look forward to hearing from you.
  • I didn't share this in the post, but I too have been in this situation before...


    I was dating a guy that didn't treat me very well - we fought all the time and I suspected him of cheating on several occasions. There was just something about him that made me keep going back, some kind of chemistry that I couldn't explain.




    About 1.5 years into this relationship, I met another guy that really, really liked me and I really fell for him. I wanted desperately to be with him but for some reason, I just couldn't let go of Guy #1.


    Eventually Guy #2 got tired of the game that I was playing and left. We still saw each other frequently and I never recovered. I ended up breaking up with Guy #1 several months later, but it was too late to salvage the relationship with guy #2 - he had moved on.


    I knew deep down in my heart that I wanted to be with Guy #2 even though it didn't make sense logically. I vowed to myself that in the future, I would always listed to my heart in 'matters of the heart' - not logic.


    I was given this test again when I met Dan. This time I didn't hesitate because I knew Dan was the right one for me at this time in my life. Many people disagreed with my decision to leave my previous relationship, but for me, it has proven to be the right decision.


    Society teaches us that we need to choose at a very early age the one person that we're going to spend the rest of our life with.


    I don't subscribe to this belief system. I believe that different people come into our lives at different times and for different purposes. We should embrace each and every experience, and relationship, with love and acceptance.


    So I guess what I'm trying to say in all of this rambling is that you will have to make a decision and when that time comes, Follow Your Heart.

  • LebKing
    To Both Sarah and Jen,

    Attraction is not a choice, it just happens. Both of your guy #2 stir such strong feelings of attraction because they have a wild side about them where you know they are harder to pin down and so you are in the chase because of the thrill. You are trying to domesticate them

    Guy #1 however, has already been caught, if you know what I mean. You like what you see and you are happy with him but the excitement is not as great as he represents stability and responsibility. He does not bring out the wild side in you.

    The best way to rectify this, as guy #1 seems like the logical choice (though attraction is never logical), is to get him to go out and have fun more, take up a hobby or participate in an activity or something like that so that he is more out there and enjoying other things in life besides you.

    These are all things I have learnt from Joseph Matthews and David DeAngelo so look them up if you are interested.

    Lebking
  • Sarah
    Thnakyou everyone for your great responses. However,
    in response to Dan and Jennifer's post - my problem is that my heart says I love them both for different reasons. So following my heart unfortunately doesn't help me here.
    In response to Lebking's post - I dont think my lack of attraction for guy#1 and attraction for guy#2 is due to any perception of wildness. I think it is more a physical thing, and has to do with each man's looks, body, and chemical attraction for me. With guy#2 there is passion, whereas with guy#1 there is not.
    I know there is no easy answer here, even though I suppose that is what Jen and I are desperately hoping for :(
  • jessie
    Hi, Sarah:

    I am in the same situation as you and they both want to marry me, but one of them asked my parents for my hands in marriage today. I dont 't know what to do.
  • Susan
    Hello everybody,

    I can say I had the same experience before, and I am still not decided. If you really HAVE To choose, imagine you are walking on a road, this road divides by 2, left side is guy#1, right side is guy#2, beleive me, you will choose one particular path, and that will show you who you love most. Even if you love them both, you do not love them equally!!! I hope it helps :)
    For me, the problem is, do you want to live with the one you love more or the one who loves you more!!!
blog comments powered by Disqus